Black Otter Supper Club
Home of Wisconsin's Famous Extreme 32oz+ Prime Rib Cuts
About Black Otter Supper Club
Legendary destination known statewide for massive portion sizes, King Cut prime rib, salad bar, and cozy Wisconsin pub atmosphere.
Why Fox Valley Locals Love It
Authentic Wisconsin hospitality, local ingredients, and signature recipes that make Black Otter Supper Club a standout staple in Hortonville.
Signature Highlights & Specialty Items
32oz King Cut Prime Rib
Top-rated local recommendation
Full Salad Bar
Top-rated local recommendation
Grasshoppers
Top-rated local recommendation
Features & Offerings
Salad Bar Full Bar Dine-In Friday Fish Fry
More Spots to Explore in Fox Valley
Hand-picked local pizzerias & dining recommendations nearby
Supper Club & Steakhouse
4.7
Mark's East Side
Appleton's Iconic Traditional Wisconsin Supper Club & German Specialties
Appleton$$$
Supper Club & Steakhouse
4.6
George's Steak House
Historic Piano Lounge & Premier Fox Valley Steakhouse
Appleton$$$
Steakhouse & Supper Club
4.6
Red Ox Seafood & Steakhouse
Cozy Southside Steak & Seafood Supper Club Landmark
Appleton$$$