Sal's Pizza
Authentic New York Style Slice Shop on College Ave
4.7(480 local reviews)
Downtown Appleton, Appleton
pizza Specialty
About Sal's Pizza
Downtown Appleton staple serving giant NY-style slices, hand-tossed pies, garlic knots, and calzones.
Why Fox Valley Locals Love It
Authentic Wisconsin hospitality, local ingredients, and signature recipes that make Sal's Pizza a standout staple in Appleton.
Signature Highlights & Specialty Items
Giant NY Slices
Top-rated local recommendation
Garlic Knots
Top-rated local recommendation
Late Night Slices
Top-rated local recommendation
Features & Offerings
Counter Service Dine-In & Takeout Late Night
More Spots to Explore in Fox Valley
Hand-picked local pizzerias & dining recommendations nearby